Re: [Corpora-List] The genre of the Web

From: Mark P. Line (mark@polymathix.com)
Date: Sun Sep 18 2005 - 21:27:34 MET DST

  • Next message: Siegfried Handschuh: "[Corpora-List] Call for Participation : ISWC 05 Markup and Annotation Workshop"

    John F. Sowa wrote:
    > I agree with Mark Lane on that point:
    >
    > > I don't think of the Web as a genre at all.
    >
    > On the other hand, it's not clear that the web
    > is a medium.
    >
    > > It's a very flexible medium, in fact, because
    > > it seems to carry all genres effectively.
    >
    > In that regard, it's more like a very dynamic
    > library. But it is also as interactive as
    > telephones or video games (which it carries
    > as well).

    For me, a medium is anything that can carry content. The concept is useful
    because it allows us to reify content from the many media that might carry
    it, and to reify media from the many kinds of content they might carry.

    There are media for static content as well as media for dynamic content,
    and there are media for storage as well as media for retrieval and
    transmission, but they're all media to my mind.

    I certainly think of the telephone system as a medium, and specific
    console game platforms are media. Even a library is a medium, because a
    library is not the same as the set of books it carries (its content): A
    large conical pile ready to light the match is also a set of books, but it
    is not a library. The content is not the medium.

    When I choose to think of the Web as a medium, I am emphasizing its role
    as the carrier for an exploding variety of content modalities. All that
    content, even dynamic content, is still ultimately just a set of
    datafiles. You can have all the files you want, but they're nothing
    without the medium -- nothing without the Web.

    -- Mark

    Mark P. Line
    Polymathix
    San Antonio, TX



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Sun Sep 18 2005 - 21:33:19 MET DST