Re: Corpora: corpus evidence that runs counter to intuition?

From: John Williams (johnw@cwcom.net)
Date: Thu Oct 18 2001 - 22:28:03 MET DST

  • Next message: Donatella Maisano: "Corpora: German language corpus"

    Sebastian Hoffmann wrote:
     
    > I'm looking for "nice" examples where corpus evidence (radically)
    > runs counter to intuition (of a native speaker) or to standard
    > perception of the language. Of course there are many findings in
    > corpus-based studies that could not have been established by
    > introspection - but I'm looking for the kind which would result in a
    > "wow - I wouldn't have thought that!"-reaction from the average
    > language user. ;-)

    ---
    

    Dear Sebastian,

    In the Bank of English, by far the most frequent meaning of 'bash' (any part of speech) is 'party' whereas I think most native speakers would intuitively go for 'hit, beat up' (informal). This could be explained by the large news media component of the BofE ('bash = party' is very much a 'media' word) or maybe it's 'really' the most frequent meaning (whatever that means).

    The large news component also explains things like the main verb collocates of 'radio station' being things like 'capture' or 'take over', rather than the more intuitive 'listen to' or 'tune into'.

    And also there are the well-known cases like 'give', where the delexicalized meanings ('give a smile', etc) are more frequent than 'hand over, present'; and 'see = understand' which is more frequent than 'see = perceive with eyes'.

    Hope this helps.

    John Williams, ex-Cobuild lexicographer

    --

    *** STOP THIS SENSELESS WAR ***

    John Williams

    Tel/Fax: (+44) (0)151 733 5459 Mobile: (+44) (0)7968 027829

    Web: http://www.eflex.mcmail.com

    E-mail: johnw@cwcom.net (business, home) johnw@whoever.com (anything, anywhere)

    *** STOP THIS SENSELESS WAR ***



    This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Thu Oct 18 2001 - 23:05:08 MET DST